Printables · November 19, 2026
Christmas Would You Rather Questions for Kids
Christmas would you rather questions for kids, sorted by age from cocoa-cozy to tween-tricky, plus a quick Christmas this or that round and four ways to play.
Good Christmas would you rather questions for kids give two festive, slightly ridiculous choices and no wrong answer. Sort them by age: four to six-year-olds want reindeer, snowmen and cookies, seven to nine love the silly and the gross, and ten to twelve want a choice that is honestly hard to make. Below are 36 questions we wrote for December, sorted by age, plus a rapid-fire Christmas this or that round for mixed groups and four ways to run it. Read them off your phone or copy them onto paper strips, and you have a game for the car, the dinner table or the class party!
Four ways to play it
You need nothing but the questions and a room full of kids.
- Snowball sides. One side of the room is the first answer, the other side is the second. Read the question, count down from three, and everyone moves. Great for wiggly little ones and for kids who would rather not talk.
- Hand-up vote at the table. Perfect for Christmas dinner. Read one, everyone votes, and the smallest voter picks the next.
- Defend your pick. Older kids answer in turn and get ten seconds to argue for it. The group decides who made the best case, not who picked “right.”
- Stocking draw. Write each question on a strip, fold it and drop it in a stocking. Kids take turns pulling one out and reading it aloud, which readers love and pre-readers can do with a helper.
Play for ten minutes, then switch to something louder. Our Christmas party games for kids has the games to put on either side of it.
Cozy Christmas questions (ages 4 to 6)
Keep these sweet and simple. Short choices, things they can picture, and nothing about Santa skipping anyone’s house.
Would you rather…
- ride in Santa’s sleigh or ride on a reindeer’s back?
- build a snowman or make a snow angel?
- have a cookie as big as your head or a cup of cocoa as big as a bathtub?
- be an elf who makes toys or an elf who wraps presents?
- have a pet penguin or a pet polar bear?
- decorate the tree with all red ornaments or all gold ones?
- wear a sweater with a reindeer on it or a sweater with a snowman on it?
- have a nose that glows red like Rudolph’s or ears that jingle like bells?
- sleep in a snow fort or in a gingerbread house?
- eat candy canes for breakfast or sugar cookies for lunch?
- be a snowflake floating in the sky or a star on top of the tree?
- leave Santa carrots or leave Santa cookies?
Silly and gross Christmas questions (ages 7 to 9)
This age wants to laugh until milk comes out of their nose. Keep the gross funny and the choices fast.
Would you rather…
- eat a gingerbread man with ketchup on top or a candy cane dipped in mustard?
- have to talk like an elf all day or walk like a penguin all day?
- find a frog in your stocking or a stocking full of socks you already own?
- have tinsel for hair or ornaments hanging from your ears?
- live in a snow globe or inside a giant advent calendar?
- sneeze glitter every time you laugh or hiccup jingle bells every time you eat?
- be stuck in a chimney for an hour or stuck in a snowbank for an hour?
- have reindeer antlers that never fall off or a red nose that never stops glowing?
- only be able to eat green food on Christmas or only red food?
- wrap every present in the house or unwrap them all with your eyes closed?
- have a snowball fight against your parents or against your teachers?
- open all your presents at 5 a.m. or wait until after lunch?
Tricky Christmas questions (ages 10 to 12)
Tweens like questions that make the group argue. The best ones have no obvious answer.
Would you rather…
- have Christmas twice a year with half the presents or once a year with all of them?
- spend Christmas somewhere snowy or somewhere with a beach?
- know every present before you open it or never find out who gave you what?
- get one big present you really want or ten small surprises?
- be in charge of Christmas dinner or in charge of the Christmas playlist?
- have your gift wrapping always look perfect or always finish wrapping in five minutes?
- give a present that makes someone cry happy tears or get one that makes you cry happy tears?
- spend Christmas Eve at a giant family party or a quiet night with just your family?
- skip the presents and go on a trip, or stay home and get the presents?
- have it snow every day in December or never have to wear a coat all winter?
- run Santa’s workshop for a year or be a reindeer for a single Christmas Eve?
- give up Christmas cookies or give up Christmas music?
Christmas this or that: the speed round
This or that is would you rather on fast forward: two words, pick one, no explaining. It works brilliantly with a mixed group, because a four-year-old and a twelve-year-old can play the same round. Read them quickly and let kids point or shout.
- Santa or Rudolph?
- Candy cane or gingerbread?
- Snowman or snow angel?
- Hot cocoa or warm cider?
- Sledding or skating?
- Wrapping paper or gift bags?
- Christmas Eve or Christmas morning?
- Red or green?
- Stockings or presents under the tree?
- Twinkle lights or plain white lights?
- Pajamas all day or a fancy outfit?
- Build a fort or bake cookies?
Twelve rounds take about three minutes: the perfect filler while someone hunts for the tape.
Keeping it fun for mixed ages
At a family party the preschooler and the tween share one circle. Read the youngest list first, while the little ones are still listening, then move to the tricky questions and make the small kids the cheering “judges.”
Keep naughty-or-nice talk out of it. Not every child celebrates the same way, and nobody needs a North Pole debate at a class party. Swap “Christmas” for “winter” in the this or that list and it plays just the same.
If your crowd loved this, our evergreen list of would you rather questions for kids has more than a hundred more for the rest of the year, and the Halloween would you rather set is ready for next October.
Make your own Christmas questions
By round three the kids will want to write their own. The formula: two choices that are both fun, or both a little awful, and close to equal. “Cookie or broccoli” is not a question. “One cookie the size of a pizza or a hundred the size of a coin” is.
FAQ
What are good Christmas would you rather questions for kids?
Ones with two fun or two silly choices and no right answer, like “would you rather ride in Santa’s sleigh or on a reindeer’s back?” Match them to age: simple and cozy for preschoolers, gross and silly for early elementary, and tricky trade-offs for tweens.
What is Christmas this or that?
A quick version of would you rather where you name two Christmas things, like “candy cane or gingerbread?”, and players pick one without explaining. It is fast, it needs no reading, and it works for every age at once.
How do you play would you rather at a Christmas party?
The easiest way is snowball sides: one side of the room for each answer, and kids move on “three.” For a dinner table, do a hand-up vote. For older kids, let each player defend their choice.
Pick your favorites, save them on your phone, and you have a game ready for every December gathering from the class party to Christmas dinner. Have fun, friend!